/*NSG-M2*/ /*NSG-M2*/

Sunday, September 6, 2009

Monday's Muse - Mom Wars

Cat fights and cattiness. Bickering and downright b!#chiness. Let's face it, women have a reputation for fighting each other down. In the stereotypical example, the cheating husband slinks off while the wife and the mistress battle it out. If you listen to the media, the battle is taking shape on a whole new front. It's the Mom Wars.

Check out this CBS News Special Feature clip. I haven't been able to stop thinking about it since I saw it last week, so I've made it this week's Monday's Muse topic.

Seems the media is having a field day playing up the "VERSUS" angle - Alpha vs Beta. I get why the "Alpha Mom" would have caught the spotlight. I get how interesting it is to look at moms who manage to be successful at both that fulltime Homemaker job, as well as the Office job. I mean for most people doing either well seems to be just about all we can handle. How DO they do it. It's fascinating and worthwhile discussion. But now what you have is not "There's a group of moms with another philosophy out there" but rather "Hey these other moms think the Alpha moms have it wrong". Because reality TV's taught us everything's more exciting with a Showdown, hasn't it? "Oh, and by the way, you moms out there join in too - take our quiz and see which mom you are!" Thanks, but I don't need to know what category you think I should be pigeonholed into.

What are they missing? Well two things, really. There's more than one way to parent. Duh, there's more than TWO ways to parent. Each of us has nuances to our own personalities that are reflected in the way we parent. And the world is made up of more than 2 personality types. Even the TypeA/B personality test has a Type AB personality. There's a lot more I can say on that, but that's a whole new post.

VERSUS. Like it's a boxing match.

The big thing for me, is in this - the blogging community. Moms are blogging more than ever before (I've been blogging for less than a month). And that's got to say something. Here's what it says to me - it says that there's lots of us trying to figure out how to do it right. Not in some kind of template form, but as it comes. We want to catch our mistakes before it's too late, to learn from the experiences of others, to have have an outlet where other people just get it. So we can stay sane and manage this parenting job the only way we know how - with our own individual "flavour".

And that VERSUS. That's not what I see here. I see lots of support. I see a community that encourages and doesn't take advantage of the vulnerabilities that are put out there. At least that's been my experience. Because it doesn't matter that my house is a mess and yours is pristine. That's not where our connection lies. Even the most perfect mom has an off day. And when you do, I got your back. And even though that mom over there feels like a failure on a daily basis, some days are just sent from heaven. And I got your back then too.

So here's my take on the Mom Wars.
1: You want news? Tell me more about Beta moms. What did you find? What's the motivation? Tell me about the moms in between and about the Type A girl, who's turned out to be a Type B mom. And vice versa. But don't try to make your news on the battle of the A's against the B's.
And 2: There's no-one in the world who can relate to this job, except another mom. And we don't have to be alike, or agree with each other, (heck we don't even have to like each other) we can still connect on that level. Another something only moms will get.


Check out Cinnamon and Honey for more Monday Muses.

1581884212_57276dd550_o

6 comments:

robin said...

This is a great post! A few years ago, New York magazine ran a HUGE article about the mom wars... this area with its competitive nature and fast-paced lifestyle is a hot-bed for that kind of thing. It was a really great piece, showing both sides' point of view. If I can find the story, I'll send you the link!
Thanks for the muse!

Mandee said...

I haven't really been paying attention I guess b/c I haven't heard of this. I guess it's because I haven't been watching much tv lately. I agree with you though that there are many ways to parent a child. :)

Nicole @ WhenDidIBecomeMyMom.com said...

@robin - thanks! I'd appreciate that!

@Momma Such - that link is actually a couple yrs old, but I recently came across it. But then I came across others as well. And some attacks on another blogger, again corralling some other moms in the same kind of "VERSUS" way. Not to mention the critical eye on Mom Blogs themselves. There just seems to be a lot happening on the front these days, and I feel that a lot of effort is being expended on questioning Mothers, how we relate to each other, and Moms who choose to blog. I was actually going to post a part II to this, but since I can't get it out tomorrow, I hadn't said anything yet.

Claudya Martinez said...

This was a great post. I'm really sick of this whole pitting types against each other. It's just a way to sensationalize a topic.

Nicole @ WhenDidIBecomeMyMom.com said...

Thanks. :-)
You know I was amazed to find that I found posts as far back as 2005 on this. And in all that time it seems to have never gone away. Instead it seems to have branched out into all these different areas. I'm wondering, in a world where we're lamenting family breakdown, why are we attacking the people who hold that institution together, and their support mechanisms? Why is Successful Motherhood a less Valid career?

A Mother Always said...

Wonderful post. Every mom is unique because each child is different and they are our lives. There's no competition.

ShareThis

Related Posts with Thumbnails